Review
Bigfoot!

There is a particular joy in watching a show that knows exactly how silly it is and refuses to apologize for it, and Bigfoot!, the new musical comedy from Amber Ruffin, Kevin Sciretta, and David Schmoll, delivers that joy in heaping, hairy handfuls. Ruffin has been nursing this show since 2014, and the Manhattan Theatre Club production at New York City Center Stage I proved the wait was worth it. This is a heartfelt cryptid romp about identity, acceptance, and the corrupt politicians who profit from our fear of each other.
The story unfolds in Muddirt, a glow-in-the-dark town wedged between a chemical dump and a nuclear power plant, where Bigfoot (Grey Henson) lives hidden in the nearby forest with his mother, Francine (Crystal Lucas-Perry). He is no rampaging beast; he slips into town at night to fix whatever has broken, and he has built a detailed scale model of the community he longs to join. Francine, who is prone to fainting spells, warns him that people are not open-minded enough to be his neighbors. Meanwhile the Mayor (Alex Moffat) is quietly arranging to bulldoze the town for a water park called Splashtown, and when the townspeople start to protest, he distracts them with the First Annual Night-Smasher Hunt. Enter Joanne (Katerina McCrimmon), a hunter raised on conspiracy theories, who sets out to bag the beast and instead becomes his friend.
Ruffin has said Bigfoot stands in for trans people, the wider LGBTQ community, and immigrants, and the allegory lands without ever turning preachy. The show is set in the 1980s, but a mayor who invents a monster so his constituents won't notice he is selling them out hardly needs a footnote to feel current. The jokes never stop coming, yet the heart underneath them stays sincere, so the happy ending and its insistence that everybody deserves to belong feel earned rather than announced.

The cast is amazing from top to bottom. Henson plays Bigfoot with such guileless hope that you want to protect him from the first scene, and his voice soars from inside a fur suit that would smother a lesser performer. Lucas-Perry throws herself into every gag Francine is handed and finds real warmth in her flirtation with Jason Tam's earnest, lovestruck Doctor. Moffat makes the Mayor a gleefully oily cartoon villain, McCrimmon gets ample room to let her big voice loose, and Jade Jones nearly steals the evening in a string of supporting roles, including a water park mogul with a stick-on mustache and vocal runs to spare.
The songs, with music by Schmoll and lyrics by Ruffin, are memorable and fun, packed with lines you find yourself repeating on the subway home, and Danny Mefford's direction and choreography keep the numbers bouncing. Tim Mackabee's set is gloriously old-fashioned, with flat cutout trees gliding along tracks, and Ricky Reynoso's Bigfoot suit is a marvel.

Bigfoot! closed April 26 after just eight weeks, and I hope it comes back. It was fun from beginning to end, and a ninety-minute musical that sends you out grinning while still asking who we choose to treat as monsters is a rare and welcome creature.